Posted on

How do “Make ‘Em Laugh” and “You Were Meant For Me” contribute to the narrative in Singin’ in the Rain?

                Singin’ in the Rain is widely considered the greatest musical of Hollywood cinema and was even named fifth out of the 100 greatest movies of all time by the American Film Institute. The film falls in the musical genre, with over half the film consisting of singing and dancing, and yet the narrative of the plot is still very strong. In fact, the musical numbers in the film serve not only as entertainment but also as techniques to advance the plot narration as well as character development.

The audience’s first introduction to Don Lockwood’s character is through his recollections during an interview. While his audible recollections contrast with the images displayed, these flashbacks allow the audience to see Don’s experience and talent in singing and dancing. The first musical number that advances the narrative plot is “Make ‘Em Laugh” sung by Cosmo Brown. This song is performed after a discussion about Don’s new film The Dueling Cavalier where Don questions the quality of his acting. Cosmo sings the song “Make ‘Em Laugh” in response. While an entertaining number, this performance is used as a communication device to not only Don but also to the audience. In the exposition given through Don’s background story the audience is aware that these two are men of music-and that’s how they communicate with each other. The transition from dialogue to dance does not seem forced or unusual to the audience and because of this the viewer is able to focus on what is being sung rather than questioning the reason behind it. Cosmo’s primary goal for the performance is to cheer up Don and encourage him to continue his acting career. After all, if Cosmo can continue to get up and perform after falling to the ground and crashing into a wall then Don can still act. This routine enlightens the audience’s understanding of the close friendship between Don and Cosmo as well as establishes a theme of communicating through areas other than dialogue.

The next performance that advances the plot, and sets the tone for most of the film, is Don’s and Kathy’s “You Were Meant For Me.” This musical number follows directly after Cosmo’s “Make ‘Em Laugh” thus emphasizing the contrast between the two. Whereas “Make ‘Em Laugh” is very boisterous and advanced in style, technique, and talent, “You Were Meant For Me” is simple, yet just as important to the narrative. This routine works as a communication technique as well- to express the relationship development between Don and Kathy. Initially their dance together is slow, almost like they are simply walking, however as the song continues it becomes apparent that they are interested in each other. What begins as a shy dance turns into a routine where Don appears to be sweeping Kathy off her feet and the audience is able to see a nonverbal communication between the two- an interpersonal reciprocation of feelings for each other. This performance not only contributes to the romantic narrative but also to the narrative plot as a whole, for Kathy and Don become partners, and together they help create the remodeled film The Dancing Cavalier. Without this song and dance no relationship between the two would have been created, which would have vastly altered the plot and story.

While it is important to mention the film’s title song “Singin’ in the Rain” it is in this viewer’s opinion that the two songs already discussed are the most integral to not only advancing the narrative but also establishing it. “Singin’ in the Rain” is a performance full of emotion and character development for Don Lockwood that also acts as a turning point in the movie. However, without the musical numbers “Make ‘Em Laugh” and “You Were Meant For Me” there would not be a reason for Don to feel such elation that he forgets about the downpour he is in, and instead chooses to sing in the rain.


4 responses to “How do “Make ‘Em Laugh” and “You Were Meant For Me” contribute to the narrative in Singin’ in the Rain?

  1. The most interesting thing about both songs, for me, is that they both take place on sets, and very clearly draw attention to artifice and staging at work (Don literally “sets the stage” before his musical declaration of love; Cosmo uses the movie set to humorous advantage). The fact that both songs point out the artificial nature of moviemaking while still keeping the viewer engaged in the film itself is evidence of the skillful balance between self-referencing and storytelling that characterizes this film.

  2. rdflood ⋅

    Cosmo’s character is definitely trying to cheer Don up through his humorous routine. I believe he is also trying to give him advice to lighten up and maybe start being comedic since he isn’t secure with his acting abilities. Not only is Cosmo able to express this with music, but also through his dance routine, which in itself was quite comical. I agree that this song shows that music, as well as dance, is a great way for characters to interact without dialogue.

  3. I agree with this blog post completely. If it were not for the musical numbers “Make Em Laugh” and “You Were Meant for Me” the narrative plot aspect of the film would have been lost. I also like how you mentioned that in “You Were Meant for Me” you examined that this was how Don and Kathy were showing emotional feeling for each other through a non-verbal mean of communication that the audience can relate to.

  4. The musical numbers “Make Em Laugh” and “You Were Meant for Me” are definitely integral parts of “Singin in the Rain”. I think that the “Make Em Laugh” number could also be seen as a bit of foreshadowing to the original premiere of the Dueling Cavaliers, where Don and Lina’s performance really makes the audience laugh, even if it wasn’t the film’s intent.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s